
Iris Duane celebrates the result (Image: Getty)
Scrutiny is mounting over a post dated January 2022, which read: âI cannot wait till big lizard Lizzie kicks the bucket, not because sheâs dead but because of the absolute meltdown it will cause the British consciousness.â
The post emerged shortly after Duaneâs election victory and has triggered a political backlash across party lines. Opponents have accused the Greens of fielding a candidate who has shown âdeeply offensive and disrespectfulâ judgment.
Zack Polanski hails âseismic victoryâ for the Green Party
Originally from Bradford, Duane is one of the Greensâ newest MSPs and has previously been involved in controversial campaigning on transgender rights. This includes opposition to restrictions on gender self-identification in public facilities and pledges to challenge existing rules regarding single-sex spaces.
The Scottish Greens defended the MSP, insisting the comments were made âyears agoâ and prior to the Queenâs death in September 2022. A party spokesman said the post was âintended as a jokeâ and confirmed it had since been deleted.
However, critics have dismissed that explanation as inadequate.
Scottish Conservative MSP Murdo Fraser condemned the remarks, saying: âHer late Majesty devoted her life to public service and was admired in Scotland and around the world for doing so.â

Queen Elizabeth II (Image: Getty)
Mr Fraser continued: âThese disgraceful comments from this newly elected Green MSP are deeply offensive and disrespectful. Most Scots will find them abhorrent.â
He also demanded clarity from the Scottish Greens, questioning whether the party condemns the remarks âunequivocallyâ.
Reform UK also attacked the post, describing it as âappallingâ and âdeeply disrespectful,â and called on both Duane and the party leadership to issue a full apology.
A spokesperson said: âWishing death upon Her late Majesty, especially during a period of declining health, is beyond the bounds of decency and reflects extremely poor judgment. Duane should issue a full apology, as should the Scottish Greens for fronting the candidate.â
Despite the controversy, Duane addressed supporters after winning election, focusing on representation rather than the backlash, saying: âI know that some will focus on the fact that I am the first black MSP and one of the first openly trans MSPs, but thatâs not what this election was about.â
The controversy comes amid a broader shift in the Scottish Greensâ parliamentary representation, with fellow new MSP Q Manivannan also elected on Friday for the Edinburgh and Lothians East seat.
Q Manivannan, who is also transgender, told supporters: âI am to some in this country everything that the hateful despise and I am standing here as your MSP now with care.â
The Greens have not indicated whether any disciplinary action will be taken over Duaneâs comments, while opposition parties continue to press for a formal apology and clarification on the partyâs position.


